Saturday, September 03, 2016

Bioethics and its better self

Renee Fox is one of the most, if not the most, distinguished American sociologists alive. If anything, this makes the attention that she has devoted to bioethics and bioethics workers all the more surprising, because after all, how interesting or important ARE we as subjects? She clearly would not agree with my assessment. She has written a whole book on it (Observing Bioethics, with Judith Swazey), and recently published a talk entitled "Moving bioethics toward its better self: a sociologist's perspective", where she clearly and unapologetically has gone from observing bioethics to prescriptively stating what bioethicists ought to be doing. Of course, people telling bioethicists what to do is nothing new. Some make a career out of lumping all bioethicists together and lambasting them as a band of heartless utilitarians promoting a culture of death. Fox is a more astute and gentler critic. For one thing, she apparently thinks bioethics has a 'better self', and that it can be nudged in that direction.

So where does Fox think bioethics is now, such that it needs a good nudge? First, its focus is narrow, concentrating on a relatively limited set of phenomena in biology, medicine and medical technology, particularly as they relate to the beginning and end of life. In understanding the ethical issues related to these phenomenon, bioethics goes back to the well of one particular value (autonomy) over and over again, to the neglect of other values like the common good, solidarity and social justice. The comfort zone of bioethics is the individual or interpersonal level of analysis: it appeals strongly to moral imagination (because you can imagine 'what you would do' in a certain case) as well as resonating with traditional American individualism. Ascending to a more macro level of analysis -- social determinants of health and political forces impacting health but lying outside medicine -- pull bioethics more outside its comfort zone. For similar reasons, global health ethics, and appreciating other ways of how ethics is conducted around the world, are still marginalized interests within bioethics. Fox is also underwhelmed by talk of an 'empirical turn' in bioethics, arguing that the field has not yet seriously stepped outside its academic haven and embraced the lived experiences of patients, researchers, patients and their families. Worse still, what is supposed to be the bread and butter of bioethics, debate and argumentation, is shot through with timidity. In her experience, Doctors without Borders has more vigorous discussion and self-examination than your average bioethics center.

So what is the recipe for getting to a 'better self'? Fox does not spell it out, but you get the idea. Open up the range of topics as to what counts as a 'bioethics question'. Stop fixating on autonomy and make room for other values worth caring about. Get a passport, then use it. Don't skim a couple of articles from social science journals and think you now have a deep acquaintance with 'the facts'. And argue, dammit, rather than just pointing out problems and simply stating recommendations or 'points to consider'.

Fox is worried about the current state of bioethics, because she believes it has an important social function. She is not worried about bioethicists being 'evil'. She is worried that they are is self-absorbed, tepid, and ineffectual.

Labels: , , ,

10 Comments:

Blogger Hannah Baker said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

3:44 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

If you have a problem we come with a recommendation for us, please visit my website Obat Kuat Kuat Pria Anti Ejakulisi Dini Tahan Lama 1 Jam Non-Stop , and you can visit Obat Kuat Semprot spray 100% ampuh
hope can be useful. :) Thank you

2:15 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Hello, Very pleasant data gave by you in this blog.

I truly like the way you passed your message in the blog.

keep it up.

For Medical Equipment, Visit - www.tancolabproducts.com

12:44 AM  
Blogger marko said...

Terrible things happen to great individuals, and accepting negative score is one of them. It's even conceivable you don't merit your negative rating. Your charge card organization could have incorrectly logged your installments as reprobate. Cash Advance

2:44 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Hello good people. have a nice day. good website!!

Khasiat Teripang Sebagai Obat Kanker
Alternatif Pengobatan
Walatra Gamat Emas Kapsul
Qnc Jelly Gamat
Obat Eye Care Softgel
Ace Maxs Asli
Green World Slimming Capsule
Obat Ambeien Herbal

12:27 PM  
Blogger سيو said...

تتميز شركة العنود انها تقدم الكثير من الخدمات شركة تنظيف كنب بالبخار بمكة التي يحتاج اليها الكثير وتقدم علي أعلي مستوي من الجودة والدقة وتقدمها شركة تنظيف مفروشات بالبخار بمكة بأسعار مميزة جدا ليتمكن الجميع من الحصول علي كافة الخدمات التي تقدمها شركة العنود شركة تنظيف موكيت بالبخار بمكة دون الحاجة إلي دفع الكثير من التكاليف والاموال كما أن شركة العنود تقوم بتقديم الكثير من العروض والتخفيضات علي خدماتها

5:11 AM  
Blogger سيو said...

تعمل الشركة علي تدريب العمال بشكل صيانة يونيون اير مستمر علي اعمال التركيب والصيانه واستخدام التكنولوجيا توكيل يونيون اير الحديثه في ذلك لضمان نجاح العمل ، تتميز شركة يونيون اير بالدقه والجدية في خدمة عملاء يونيون اير اداء العمل حيث انه من اهم المميزات لديها بشهادة الكثير من العملاء .

5:47 AM  
Blogger سيو said...

يتم العمل في الشركة بناءا على افضل طرق الدفاع والحراسة شركة امن وحراسة ويتم الاشراف ووضع الخطط بواسطه فريق متميز من رجال الامن والشرطة ذوى المهاره في مجال الحراسة والدفاع شركة حراسات خاصة عن النفس بمتعدد المهارات البدنية شركة امن وحراسات والجسمية والعقليه ويتم وضع الخطط المحكمه ليتم التأمين بشكل احترافي كامل مع شركة الامن والحراسة في مصر .

10:30 AM  
Blogger سيو said...

يعتبر موقعنا واحد من المواقع الكبري المتخصصة تجهيزات محلات فى اعمال تجهيزات الفنادق والمطاعم باسعار تجهيزات مطاعم متميزة جدا اعرف الكثير تجهيزات فنادق من خدمات تجهيزات الفنادق وكافة مستلزمات الفنادق المتميزة وباسعار مميزة جدا نقدمها اليكم

11:00 AM  
Blogger سيو said...

يعتبر موقعنا واحد من المواقع الكبري المتخصصة تجهيزات محلات فى اعمال تجهيزات الفنادق والمطاعم باسعار تجهيزات مطاعم متميزة جدا اعرف الكثير تجهيزات فنادق من خدمات تجهيزات الفنادق وكافة مستلزمات الفنادق المتميزة وباسعار مميزة جدا نقدمها اليكم

11:00 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home